Shorter Hours of Service Would Increase Costs

March 3, 2011
The FMCSA’s proposal to shorten the hours of service for truck drivers would increase costs and congestion but do little to improve safety, says the National Retail Federation

A proposal to limit the number of hours truck drivers spend behind the wheel each day would increase costs for businesses and consumers while undermining intended safety benefits by putting more trucks on the road during the most-congested hours, the National Retail Federation (NRF) told federal transportation officials this week.

“As a result of the current 11-hour daily driving limit, U.S. retailers have been able to achieve significant efficiencies within their supply chains and distribution networks,” says David French, NRF’s senior vice president for government relations. “Any change to this daily driving limit will upset the careful balance and efficiencies that have been achieved and require changes to those new systems and processes. In addition, such changes could result in significantly higher transportation costs and could lead to less safety as additional drivers and trucks will be required to make up for the shortfall.”

Proposed changes would increase transportation costs by anywhere from 3% to 20% depending on a specific retailer’s supply chain network and operations, “and would adversely impact the U.S. economy,” French says.

French’s remarks came in comments filed with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) in response to a proposal that would potentially decrease the current 11-hour on-duty hours of service limit for drivers in effect since the beginning of 2004 to a 10-hour limit. In addition, the 34 hours of time off currently required between each week of driving would now have to include at least two midnight-to-6 a.m. periods of nighttime rest.

Supporters of the proposal say it would result in fewer fatigued drivers on the road and help reduce accidents. But NRF is concerned that shortening the daily driving limit would require more drivers and more trucks to move the same volume of goods during the same time period. That would increase congestion on the nation’s already overcrowded highways, NRF suggests, which could increase the potential for accidents. NRF is particularly concerned about the requirement for nighttime rest periods because retailers use overnight deliveries extensively in order to avoid daytime road congestion, particularly in urban areas.

“The deployment of more trucks during the night separates truck and automobile interactions, contributing to increased safety,” French explains. “The proposed change … reduces the ability to schedule deliveries at night, placing more trucks on the road during normal commuting hours. This adversely affects a retailer’s supply chain performance, potentially increasing congestion-related delays and increasing the likelihood of accidents and a result of greater truck and automobile interactions.”

FMCSA issued its proposal in December and has until July to issue final regulations.

Latest from Transportation & Distribution

#53673151@Petar Dojkic|Dreamstime
Trucking Industry Objects to DOL Rule on Contractors
#64128824@Igor Groshev| Dreamstime
Analysis of Red Sea Shipping Crisis