#46633426@Keng Po Jeung|Dreamstime
Drug Test Cheating Is At Highest Rate Ever

Drug Test Cheating Is At Highest Rate Ever

June 3, 2024
The increase in substituted urine specimens was 633%, according to Quest Diagnosis.

While employers might expect there to be some cheating when it comes to workplace drug tests, the rate at which this is occurring has reached an all-time high. In the more than 30 years of annual reporting, the percentage of employees in the workplace whose drug test shows signs of tampering increased by more than six-fold in 2023, versus 2022. 

This finding is part of a new analysis of nearly 9.8 million workforce drug tests released on May 15 by Quest Diagnostics. 

The increase in substituted urine specimens in the general  workforce, a population of over 5.5 million, was 633% (0.015% in 2022 versus 0.11% in 2023). Invalid urine specimens in the general U.S. workforce increased 45.2% (0.31% in 2022 versus 0.45% in 2023). A result of substituted or invalid suggests a specimen has been tampered with in an attempt to conceal drug use.

The increasing rates of substituted or invalid specimens coincide with historically high rates of both general  workforce drug positivity and post-accident marijuana positivity.

Drug positivity in the general workforce was 5.7% in both 2022 and 2023. In 2023, in the combined workforce, urine drug positivity for all drugs was 4.6%, the same as in 2021 and 2022.

This overall positivity is the highest level in more than two decades, up more than 30% from an all-time low of 3.5% in 2010-2012 and coincides with a sharp increase of 114.3% in post-accident positivity between 2015 and 2023 in the general workforce.

"The increased rate of both substituted and invalid specimens indicates that some American workers are going to great lengths to attempt to subvert the drug testing process," said Suhash Harwani, Ph.D., senior director of Science for Workforce Health Solutions at Quest Diagnostics, in a statement.

"Given the growing acceptance and use of some drugs, particularly marijuana, it may be unsurprising that some people feel it necessary to try and cheat a drug test. It is possible that our society's normalization of drug use is fostering environments in which some employees feel it is acceptable to use such drugs without truly understanding the impact they have on workplace safety."

Similar trends were also seen in the federally mandated, safety-sensitive U.S. workforce, with substituted specimens increasing 370.6% (0.017% in 2022 versus 0.08% in 2023) and invalid rates increasing 36.7% (0.30% in 2022 versus 0.41% in 2023).

"Organizations must have sound policy and procedures to ensure employee drug testing programs have efficacy. Cheating on drug tests not only undermines workplace safety but also jeopardizes the safety of society as a whole," said Katie Mueller, a senior program manager at the National Safety Council focusing on cannabis safety, in a statement.

Marijuana Continues Upward Climb
Marijuana positivity in the general U.S. workforce increased 4.7% (4.3% in 2022 versus 4.5% in 2023). Over five years, marijuana positivity has increased 45.2%, with 2023 reaching a new peak compared to 2019 (3.1% in 2019 versus 4.5% in 2023).

Marijuana Drug Test Positivity Decreases in Federally Mandated, Safety Sensitive Workforce
In the federally mandated safety-sensitive workforce, marijuana positivity decreased nationally 3.1% year over year (0.98% in 2022 versus 0.95% in 2023).

Marijuana positivity stayed the same (1.1% in both 2022 and 2023) in states in which recreational marijuana is legal and decreased 2.2% (0.90% in 2022 versus 0.88% in 2023) in states in which medical marijuana is legal. In states in which neither recreational nor medical marijuana use is legal, marijuana positivity decreased 6.7% (0.89% in 2022 versus 0.83% in 2023) year over year and stayed the same over five years (0.83% in 2019 versus 0.83% in 2023).

"The federally mandated, safety-sensitive population has a lower rate of drug positivity, likely due to the fact that there is decreased drug use when there is an expectation of being drug tested. This is fundamentally the strength of having a drug testing program. The mere expectation of drug testing may be a deterrent, dissuading individuals from both drug use and applying for positions where such tests are standard practice," said Harwani.

Post-accident Marijuana Positivity Continues to Climb
In 2023, post-accident marijuana positivity of urine drug tests in the general workforce was 7.5%. The new peak follows a steady increase in post-accident marijuana positivity every year from 2015 to 2023. In that 9-year time frame, post-accident marijuana positivity increased 114.3%.

The Quest data aligns with other reports associating marijuana legalization with workplace injuries. A February 2024 study in the Journal of the American Medical Association found recreational marijuana laws that allow recreational marijuana sales were associated with a 10% increase in workplace injuries among individuals aged 20 to 34 years.

"As the prevalence of marijuana positives in the workforce rises, our concern grows," said Mueller. "The data show an increasing correlation between marijuana use and adverse workplace effects, prompting a call for heightened vigilance and comprehensive strategies to safeguard workplace safety and productivity."

"Most employers are highly focused on productivity, which can be achieved by improving workforce health and wellness. A well-executed drug testing program can help an organization to maintain a healthier workforce which, based on our data, could decrease the potential for accidents or other unsafe behaviors," added Harwani.

Positivity Increased in Industries Associated with Office Work
Overall drug workforce positivity increased in industries associated with "office work," such as administrative, managerial, and clerical tasks within office environments. Workforce positivity increased the following industries:

  • Real estate and lending by 17.0% (4.7% in 2022 versus 5.5% in 2023)
  • Professional, Scientific and Technical Services by 9.3% (4.3% in 2022 versus 4.7% in 2023)
  • Educational Services by 7.9% (from 3.8% in 2022 to 4.1% in 2023)
  •  Public Administration by 5.0% (4.0% in 2022 to 4.2% in 2023).

Marijuana positivity increased in 13 out of 15 industries led by Finance and Insurance which increased 35.7% (2.8% in 2022 versus 3.8% in 2023); Public Administration which increased 23.5% (1.7% in 2022 versus 2.1% in 2023); and Real Estate Rental and Leasing which increased 22.2% (5.4% in 2022 versus 6.5% in 2023).

"It isn't clear why we're seeing an increase in overall and marijuana drug positivity in office workers, but it isn't a stretch that a combination of unprecedented stress and isolation during the pandemic with work-from-home policies during and post-pandemic may be contributing to greater drug use in employees in traditionally white-collar fields," said Sam Sphar, Vice President and General Manager, Workforce Health Solutions, Quest Diagnostics, in a statement. "The results underscore the growing need for mental health support and drug education programs to ensure employees are safe and productive, whether working at home or in the office."

Urine Drug Test Positivity Among Other Drug Types
Cocaine positivity in the general workforce increased 9.1% (0.22% in 2022 versus 0.24% in 2023). Amphetamines positivity remained flat (1.5% in 2022 and 2023) and 6-AM (heroin metabolite) positivity decreased 16.7% (0.006% in 2022 versus 0.005% in 2023).

Opiates (codeine/morphine) positivity decreased 12.5% (0.16% in 2022 versus 0.14% in 2023), Opiates (hydrocodone/hydromorphone) decreased 9.4% percent (0.32% in 2022 versus 0.29% in 2023) and Oxycodone (Oxycodone/Oxymorphone) also decreased 3.6% (0.28% in 2022 versus 0.27% in 2023), continuing a downward trend over five years for all three drug categories.

Latest from Labor Management

ID 248887758 © Timon Schneider | Dreamstime.com
#171785560 © Mark Gomez | Dreamstime
DOL Announces New Actions  to ProtectH-2B Workers